I who have never known men

a novel

Pas de couverture

Jacqueline Harpman: I who have never known men (1997, Seven Stories Press)

206 pages

Langue : English

Publié 19 novembre 1997 par Seven Stories Press.

ISBN :
978-1-888363-43-2
Copied ISBN!
Numéro OCLC :
35910069

Voir sur OpenLibrary

4 étoiles (2 critiques)

11 editions

Philosophical Thought Experiment with Sci-Fi Dystopia Trappings

Aucune note

This is dressed as a sci-fi dystopia, but was very much a meditation on what it means to be human when stripped away from society and what society tells us to value. The protagonist has to carve out meaning in a world that's empty of meaning and conventional sources of it.

I surmised fairly early that this was too artsy/European to give an answer as to the premise, and I was correct.

The book generally was feminist, but less gender-specific and more universal than I expected. Late in the novel she reads Shakespeare and Don Quixote, and it's interesting to me that, never having heard a man's voice, she likely would have imagined all of the characters sounding like women.

Found it strange that the other women never named the protagonist.

Audiobook narration was well done and the reader did not try to perform in a way that was distracting.

Captivating

4 étoiles

I'm not sure why this book has been popping up everywhere recently. I picked it up off a recommendation.

I thought it was a compelling short story written from the point of view of someone born in captivity and questioning what it means to be human if everything else is stripped away.

None of the characters really matter except for the main character, which is a bit of a shame. I'm torn between wanting more to the plot versus admitting that the book has clearly told the story the author intended and that it is an acceptable artistic choice.

Like many other reviews I will echo that the last sentence is indeed hard hitting.